Class B Forums

Class B Forums (https://www.classbforum.com/forums/)
-   Class B Camper Van Reviews (https://www.classbforum.com/forums/f17/)
-   -   Hymer Aktiv versus Winnebago Travato K (https://www.classbforum.com/forums/f17/hymer-aktiv-versus-winnebago-travato-k-7712.html)

funfyzics 05-23-2018 02:03 AM

Hymer Aktiv versus Winnebago Travato K
 
Hello!

New to this forum and am having a difficult time deciding between these two campervans. We are new to RVs and like some features in both these vans. We like the idea of Voltstart as we have 2 dogs and like being able to leave them in the van. However Travato doesn't offer this option. Are there any after market applications that would work? My wife and I would really like to read any thoughts or suggestions.

Thank you!

Brian and Jaye

cruising7388 05-23-2018 02:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by funfyzics (Post 73116)
Hello!

New to this forum and am having a difficult time deciding between these two campervans. We are new to RVs and like some features in both these vans. We like the idea of Voltstart as we have 2 dogs and like being able to leave them in the van. However Travato doesn't offer this option. Are there any after market applications that would work? My wife and I would really like to read any thoughts or suggestions.

Thank you!

Brian and Jaye

The Travato does provide an autostart feature if you go for the Pure 3 Volta/lithium battery option.

wincrasher 05-23-2018 03:31 AM

Winnebago is taking orders for their vans with the Pure3 system with deliveries starting in July & August.

This system has the biggest battery pack available in a Promaster, bar none. It's more than double the size of what you can get from Hymer/Roadtrek. With it's 48v 2nd alternator, it can fully recharge in 1.5 hours.

What that means is that you can run the air conditioner (by my estimation) 6 to 8 hours. Possibly indefinitely with their autostart and the 2nd alternator quick charging. You just can't do that with the Hymer. There are also issues with the Hymer with their autostart (Voltrek) working properly, and their small battery packs having a high parasitic load from their BMS also diminishing performance.

Phoebe3 05-23-2018 01:57 PM

What Wincrasher said.

warpig 05-23-2018 03:04 PM

Just curious why you are considering the Aktiv and 59K & not the 59G. The Aktiv and 59K have different floor plans while the Aktiv and 59G share a similar floor plan. One bonus that many dog owners with the Aktiv and 59G have shared is the area under the bed (when down) makes for a great dog bed. There are many varying user experiences with the Eco Trek system. It seems from what I have read that there is a learning curve to the system but some of the problems that occur result from user error.

Oliver2017 05-24-2018 01:24 AM

If you care about your passengers, the Aktiv has shoulder belts for the bench seat behind the driver...:hide:

jon 05-24-2018 04:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oliver2017 (Post 73193)
If you care about your passengers, the Aktiv has shoulder belts for the bench seat behind the driver...:hide:

I second this. I actually like that the Safari Condo Flex 21 has actual passenger seats for the second row of the front dinette but it isn't available in the shorter EB length.

funfyzics 05-24-2018 06:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phoebe3 (Post 73130)
What Wincrasher said.

Are suggesting the Crossfit. I don't think it has an inverter so wouldn't 110V appliances have to be run off generator

Phoebe3 05-24-2018 10:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by funfyzics (Post 73221)
Are suggesting the Crossfit. I don't think it has an inverter so wouldn't 110V appliances have to be run off generator

Nope. I was agreeing with wincrasher that you should wait for the Travato.

The Crossfit is my signature line and gets automatically added to all of my posts. Sorry for any confusion.

funfyzics 05-25-2018 12:07 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Phoebe3 (Post 73229)
Nope. I was agreeing with wincrasher that you should wait for the Travato.

The Crossfit is my signature line and gets automatically added to all of my posts. Sorry for any confusion.

No problem. How do you like the Crossfit? Will it fit in reg parking? My wife really likes it and the location of bathroom

Phoebe3 05-25-2018 02:18 AM

We really like it. I drive quite a bit and feel confident behind the wheel of the Transit. It's 22 ft, with a long overhang behind the back wheels so we tend to back into perimeter parking spaces and let the rear overhang the planter. It's a little too long for a standard parking space.

We have the dinette/twin bed version and it suits our needs. They also have an electronic sofa version. The floor plans and cabinetry are similar to a Pleasure Way I coveted.

As for the bathroom location, I created a poll here a few months back and i think the drivers side and the rear bath were about equally divided. As I recall, the arguments were that the rear bath provided more room, but the side bath allowed for a more panoramic view out of the rear of the coach.

Coachmen makes a quality product, but it does not currently have the fancy electronics you are looking for. We did not find that to be a deciding factor for us. YMMV.

Cannuck 05-28-2018 10:45 PM

I agree with WinCrasher on the battery system. We have the Hymer / Roadtrek Zion. The Ecotrek battery system works OK but nothing like whatís being described here for the new Winnebago power system. That said the power system isnít everything.

We steered away from the Winnebago products in general because we didnít like the layouts. The Zion has a great kitchen layout with a fridge above counter height. The Zion has the rear windows visible through the coach - you can actually use your rear view mirror. The bed in the one Travato was a divorce in the making. The fridge on the ground and lack of convenient storage in the other also turned us off. Hiding the rear doors / rear windows isnít something I cared for.

I think many standing in an RV on a dealer lot forget you have to be able to use and drive the thing. We thought the Zion had a far superior layout.

Good luck and happy shopping.

Oliver2017 05-29-2018 12:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cannuck (Post 73369)

The Zion has the rear windows visible through the coach - you can actually use your rear view mirror. Hiding the rear doors / rear windows isnít something I cared for. I think many standing in an RV on a dealer lot forget you have to be able to use and drive the thing.

I thought seeing out the back windows while driving was not supposed to be a big deal :confused::confused: I read using the side mirrors is the proper way to change lanes.

I was planning to order a 2019 Promaster cargo van with no rear windows. I read that over time using the side mirrors becomes a breeze. Any of the Travato or Aktiv owners find their vans difficult to drive?

avanti 05-29-2018 12:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oliver2017 (Post 73374)
I thought seeing out the back windows while driving was not supposed to be a big deal :confused::confused:

You need the rear window (or a camera) to know whether you are being followed by a cop. :whistling:

Brad1998RD 05-29-2018 04:06 PM

A big thing for me is cassette toilet versus black tank. I would much rather have a black tank versus carrying a cassette to dump it

Brad1998RD 05-29-2018 04:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by funfyzics (Post 73116)
Hello!

New to this forum and am having a difficult time deciding between these two campervans. We are new to RVs and like some features in both these vans. We like the idea of Voltstart as we have 2 dogs and like being able to leave them in the van. However Travato doesn't offer this option. Are there any after market applications that would work? My wife and I would really like to read any thoughts or suggestions.

Thank you!

Brian and Jaye

My big thing to make a decision would be a black tank versus a cassette toilet. Much rather dump a tank then mess with a heavy cassette.

gregmchugh 05-29-2018 10:20 PM

Anyone who can lift 40 lb should not have any trouble dumping a 5 gallon cassette when full. Consider giving it a try before you dismiss it. I do it easily and it is located about 5 ft off the ground on our vehicle and I am what would be classified as an old fart... :)

Davydd 05-29-2018 11:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by gregmchugh (Post 73415)
Anyone who can lift 40 lb should not have any trouble dumping a 5 gallon cassette when full. Consider giving it a try before you dismiss it. I do it easily and it is located about 5 ft off the ground on our vehicle and I am what would be classified as an old fart... :)

I'm an old fart and 40 lbs. is too heavy and getting heavier every year. If there is an alternative to cassettes or lifting a stinky toilet and urine bucket (composting) I'm all for it. Oh wait! There is. It's that USA preferred method of black and grey holding tanks and gravity or pumping into a hose right into a hole in the ground.

I had to dump exactly twice on our recent 37 day trip and will dump once again now that I am home. That's once every 12 days and takes less than 10 minutes from start to finish. The largest tanks one can have is the key.

BBQ 05-30-2018 12:53 AM

.

I have absolutely no interest in lowering a shxt box from five feet off the ground.

:-D :-D :-D

avanti 05-30-2018 12:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BBQ (Post 73422)
.

I have absolutely no interest in lowering a shxt box from five feet off the ground.

:-D :-D :-D

I can't say that it was one of the high points of our Iceland RV rental experience.


All times are GMT. The time now is 03:10 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.8 Beta 4
Copyright ©2000 - 2020, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.