Does an AGM Coach Battery Require an AGM Engine Battery?

Thread Summary

Summarized on:
Original Member Title: does the engine battery have to be glass mat when the coach one is?
This AI-generated summary may contain inaccuracies. Please refer to the full thread for complete details.
A member with a 2019 Travato 59K asked whether its AGM coach battery requires an AGM engine battery after a dealer offered a non-AGM replacement. One member said matching chemistries is not necessarily required, and another reported using different battery types without apparent problems, though neither established the requirements for this Travato.

Members also discussed ventilation because the Promaster engine battery sits beneath the driver-side floor. The original poster learned that a...
More...

anon125

Senior Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2006
Posts
206
our 2019 travato 59k uses a regular glass mat battery in the coach. not lithium.
the engine battery is seven years old and the chrysler dealer wants to replace it.
they offered a non glass mat battery.
I vaguely seem to almost remember that both had to be glass mat to connect with each other.
any ideas?
thanks
winnebago were no help this rime. usually they are very helpful.
 
A 2019 Promaster doesn't have Stop/start feature, so I would say no AGM needed as AGM appears to be only needed and recommended for stop start and hybrid vehicles.

It is possible, and maybe likely, that the alternator charge profile is not totally compatible for AGM with too high a voltage settings on long term driving, which will dry out an AGM.

The "don't add water" chemistry" wet cells seem to be very good and even better than a deep cycle at surviving the low state of charge, high voltage, charging in modern cars made before start stop.

We typically get in the 7-9 year life out of good wet cells in our vehicles and have found East Penn batteries to be the best by quite a bit. Cheap batteries don't hold up all that well in most cases.
 
Electrical is my weak area and my van is an 02 so older than you. I would hope by 2019 they put in a decent converter charger? I have upgraded the single stage battery killer charger to a 4 stage modern converter charger. When I bought the van it had a sealed lead acid battery and the house battery was a AGM. I have been using this for 4 years and do not see any ill effects. I also added a solenoid so when the van is on shore power, which is most of the time, both batteries are charging.
 
our 2019 travato 59k uses a regular glass mat battery in the coach. not lithium.
the engine battery is seven years old and the chrysler dealer wants to replace it.
they offered a non glass mat battery.
I vaguely seem to almost remember that both had to be glass mat to connect with each other.
any ideas?
thanks
winnebago were no help this rime. usually they are very helpful.
The Promaster chassis battery is under the driver side floor. I believe this is why it is AGM as there is no offgassing that you get with a lead acid battery. I am surprised that the dealer would want to install a non AGM battery.
 
Apparently there is a kind of engine battery with a tube connection on the side where the gasses are vented outside! NOT AN AGM!
 

Attachments

  • travato engine battery.jpg
    travato engine battery.jpg
    160.3 KB · Views: 35
The AGMs I bought at Costco to replace my Transit coach batteries last year had the tube connections, and the original factory AGMs had them too; the Transit has the batteries under the driver's seat & has vent tubes to hook up to the batteries. As long as your Promaster has a vent tube to connect to the battery if it needs one I wouldn't think it would matter whether you bought a battery with or without a vent; if you don't have a vent tube then I would make sure to purchase a sealed battery without a vent.

As I understand it, AGMs generally don't produce gasses but can do so under adverse conditions, so some AGM batteries have a vent connection with a valve that only vents the gasses if the internal pressure gets too high.
 
Last edited:
our 2019 travato 59k uses a regular glass mat battery in the coach. not lithium.
the engine battery is seven years old and the chrysler dealer wants to replace it.
they offered a non glass mat battery.
I vaguely seem to almost remember that both had to be glass mat to connect with each other.
any ideas?
thanks
winnebago were no help this rime. usually they are very helpful.
My 2017 Roadtrek came with an AGM battery wired in parallel with the Lithium Ecotrek batteries, so no.
 
My 2017 Roadtrek came with an AGM battery wired in parallel with the Lithium Ecotrek batteries, so no.
The AGM in place with the Ecotrek was a fix for the issue of not being able to wake up the lithium batteries after a BMS shutdown for whatever reason. The charging systems won't come on to do the recharging if they don't see a battery in the system.

It was common for the early systems without the AGM to go into cold shutdown of the lithium to protect the batteries and they could not get any power for the coach until the van and batteries were heated up enough to get the lithium out of shutdown. It could be very hard to do when the batteries were not inside the van so the units would have to be moved indoors in some cases to warm up.

The AGM in those systems are said to fail quite quickly do to the voltage mismatches so frequently replaced.

This is the reason so many of the lithium systems are now inside the van which makes reheating the batteries much easier to do by running the engine and van heat.

Hymer did try making and selling a combination lithium and AGM system in Europe and it never caught on and was ended quite quickly. A few systems were tried by forum members here with some success.
 
Anon 125 wrote:
Apparently there is a kind of engine battery with a tube connection on the side where the gasses are vented outside! NOT AN AGM!

My previous Jeep Grand Cherokee (2011) had a conventional lead acid battery located under the passenger seat and had such a vent in the compartment. It was extremely difficult to get to and I only replaced it once. My aging bod just didn't want to do it so I took it to Pep Boys and a guy about 25 with arms bigger than my legs was almost upside down taking it out and installing a new one. The vent was for the compartment and was NOT for the battery. It was a just a plain ole battery.
 
The AGM in place with the Ecotrek was a fix for the issue of not being able to wake up the lithium batteries after a BMS shutdown for whatever reason. The charging systems won't come on to do the recharging if they don't see a battery in the system.

It was common for the early systems without the AGM to go into cold shutdown of the lithium to protect the batteries and they could not get any power for the coach until the van and batteries were heated up enough to get the lithium out of shutdown. It could be very hard to do when the batteries were not inside the van so the units would have to be moved indoors in some cases to warm up.

The AGM in those systems are said to fail quite quickly do to the voltage mismatches so frequently replaced.

This is the reason so many of the lithium systems are now inside the van which makes reheating the batteries much easier to do by running the engine and van heat.

Hymer did try making and selling a combination lithium and AGM system in Europe and it never caught on and was ended quite quickly. A few systems were tried by forum members here with some success.
The original AGM in my 2017 Roadtrek is still going strong. It's one of the few components in the system I haven't had problems with. I don't know how many years of Roadtrek production used the AGM Lithium combinantion, or if they still do, but many owners I've communicated with online have commented on the amazing longevity of the under hood AGM in their Ecotrek system. The combination was definitely used for at least a few years.
 
The original AGM in my 2017 Roadtrek is still going strong. It's one of the few components in the system I haven't had problems with. I don't know how many years of Roadtrek production used the AGM Lithium combinantion, or if they still do, but many owners I've communicated with online have commented on the amazing longevity of the under hood AGM in their Ecotrek system. The combination was definitely used for at least a few years.
Very interesting. You must be doing something right in maintaining the AGM charge that others haven't. I think one issue may be that the Ecotrek modules were recommended to be shut off when not in use to prevent the very large parasitic draw from discharging them, but when they are shut off, the AGM from the system can discharge it and shorten life. Do you have it on float shore charge when the modules are shut off? Or perhaps they changed the system up a bit over the early versions.

Here is a link to a 2020 discussion on here about the Ecotrek which all were still learning about then. The AGM was said to be running mostly at about 40% SOC with little capacity to be the only battery once the Ecotrek modules were off or in shutdown.

Link to thread
 
Very interesting. You must be doing something right in maintaining the AGM charge that others haven't. I think one issue may be that the Ecotrek modules were recommended to be shut off when not in use to prevent the very large parasitic draw from discharging them, but when they are shut off, the AGM from the system can discharge it and shorten life. Do you have it on float shore charge when the modules are shut off? Or perhaps they changed the system up a bit over the early versions.

Here is a link to a 2020 discussion on here about the Ecotrek which all were still learning about then. The AGM was said to be running mostly at about 40% SOC with little capacity to be the only battery once the Ecotrek modules were off or in shutdown.

Link to thread
Thanks, I participated in the thread you linked to. I've never done anything to my AGM. Roadtreks have a solar charger that charges the AGM constantly even when the Ecotreks are turned off although I store my van under cover so there is little or no output from the solar panels when it's stored for months at a time, which is typical for me. I've checked the voltage of the AGM after long periods of storage and not found it to be discharged.
 

Try RV LIFE Pro Free for 7 Days

  • New Ad-Free experience on this RV LIFE Community.
  • Plan the best RV Safe travel with RV LIFE Trip Wizard.
  • Navigate with our RV Safe GPS mobile app.
  • and much more...
Try RV LIFE Pro Today
Back
Top